Theft and Fraud Offenses

Camden County NJ Theft Crime Lawyer

Criminal Defense Attorney Representing Clients Across New Jersey

Theft and fraud is a broad classification of offenses in New Jersey, encompassing crimes ranging from shoplifting to prescription fraud. These crimes are highly variable in terms of the degree of the charges and the potential penalties associated with a conviction. However, a conviction for any theft or fraud crime may leave you exposed to consequences including heavy fines, restitution payments, community service, and jail time. In addition, all of these offenses fall within the realm of “crimes of moral turpitude.” This is significant because a conviction may also negatively impact your immigration status, and even result in deportation, if you are not currently a United States citizen. When faced with such overwhelming repercussions, it is critical to protect yourself and your innocence.

Criminal defense attorney William Fay has dedicated his legal career to the practice of criminal justice in New Jersey. He began defending clients charged with criminal offenses including theft by deception, identity theft, extortion, and passing bad checks in Burlington County, Camden County, Gloucester County, and South Jersey after serving as a Deputy Attorney General for the New Jersey Attorney General’s Office. Due to his extensive knowledge and experience, Mr. Fay has achieved countless positive outcomes on behalf of clients. Whether your best outcome is a dismissal at trial, enrollment in a diversionary program such as the Conditional Dismissal Program, probation, or a negotiated plea to a lesser sentence, Mr. Fay will work tirelessly to secure the most favorable result. To discuss your case with Mr. Fay and find the answers to your questions, contact his offices today at 609-832-3202 for a cost-free consultation.

Do I Need an Attorney for Theft Charges in Voorhees NJ?

Great question. It is always advisable for an individual facing criminal charges to obtain legal counsel. Whether this representation is through from a private law firm or an appointed public defender, the option for legal assistance is always available. Our office has provided legal representation to multiple clients facing criminal charges in New Jersey for conduct involving theft and fraud. Specifically, we have handled cases involving some of the following:

Is Theft a Felony or Misdemeanor in New Jersey?

Theft charges exist on a spectrum, and many are graded based on the monetary benefit derived in the course of committing the offense. Specifically:

  • Theft of less than $200 are typically disorderly persons offenses. This is not a felony, but is a criminal misdemeanor nonetheless. The punishments can include jail for up to 6 months and a fine of up to $1,000.
  • Theft of between $200 and $500 worth of property is a fourth degree crime, as is forgery in most cases. This is a felony offense, otherwise known as an indictable crime. Penalties for this level of offense can include up to 18 months in state prison and a fine of up $10,000.
  • Theft of between $500 and $75,000 worth of property is graded as a third degree indictable crime. This felony offense also applies to burglary, auto theft, and making fraudulent credit cards. The consequences of a conviction can include fines up to $15,000 plus a prison sentence of 3 to 5 years.
  • Theft of property worth over $75,000 becomes a second degree crime, a serious felony with a presumption of incarceration for anyone, even those with no criminal past. The potential repercussions of being found guilty can involve up to 10 years of imprisonment and a fine not to exceed $150,000.
  • First degree theft charges typically involve serious threat of injury along with a theft crime. These include things like armed robbery and carjacking. Depending on the specific crime charged, you may face anywhere from 10 to 30 years in prison. Some of these charges also require you to serve 85 percent of the entire sentence before coming up for parole.

It is important to note that some offenses entail mandatory community service and other penalties. Those convicted may also be required to pay restitution to the victim(s) or the merchant from whom property was stolen. Theft and fraud crimes are also moral turpitude offenses, meaning the collateral impacts can include deportation or damaging effects with immigration.

Proving Theft and Defending Against Theft Charges in New Jersey

For a theft charge to stick, the prosecutor must prove that someone intended to take someone else’s belongings without intending to return it. Circumstantial evidence can be used to prove intent. So, if someone sits down at a restaurant and finds another person’s wallet on the seat, they may be charged with theft if they take the wallet home and make no efforts to return the wallet to its rightful owner. However, if they take the wallet home and try to find the owner with no success, the intent to permanently deprive someone of their wallet is missing and therefore no theft charge is going to be successful. Similarly, with receiving stolen goods, the knowledge that the goods received are stolen may be proven by obvious signs that the person receiving the goods should have known that the items were stolen, say, by the deep discount on the items or the method of receiving the items, such as clothing with the tags still on them.

Theft, though common, is not always clear cut. The prosecutor must prove intent with facts that persuade a jury in Superior Court or a judge in Municipal Court beyond a reasonable doubt that a defendant knowingly took or kept what is not theirs from the start or after mistakenly coming upon someone else’s belongings. There is room for an experienced criminal defense attorney to cast doubt in a jury’s mind if the intent is not certain from the given facts. Depending on the case, the evidence may be thin and entirely insufficient when your lawyer starts to poke holes in the prosecution’s version of the story. For this reason, your paramount concern should be to find knowledgeable and experienced legal representation before ever consenting to a plea agreement or another outcome.

Mr. Fay will thoroughly investigate your case to identify evidence that supports your innocence. And there are other ways to get charges downgraded or dismissed, including diversionary programs like Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) in Superior Court and Conditional Dismissal in Municipal Courts. Talk to a criminal defense attorney at our firm who regularly defends clients charged with theft crimes in Camden County if you have been charged with theft. You may not know your options and possible defenses until you do.

Contact a Pennsauken NJ Theft and Fraud Lawyer for a Free Consultation

If you or someone you love has been charged with a theft or fraud offense in Camden County or elsewhere in South Jersey, it is highly advisable to consult with an experienced New Jersey criminal defense attorney as soon as possible. Contact our firm at 609-832-3202 for additional information and a cost-free consultation about your specific theft charge. We frequently appear in courts throughout Camden County, including in Lindenwold, Berlin, Winslow, Pennsauken, Cherry Hill, and Gloucester Township. To discuss your charges and how we may be of assistance, contact us 24/7.


testimonials reviews
"Excellent criminal defense lawyer"

"William handled a matter for me and exceeded my expectations. He was excellent in all areas of the law and achieved an outstanding result. Best of all,he demonstrates honesty and integrity. I would highly recommend William and already have."


testimonials reviews

"I was so scared and nervous about my legal situation but Mr. Fay did an outstanding job with my case!!! I was so relieved with the outcome and he worked so hard for me! He was so calm and understanding and I’m so grateful for him. Thank you so very much for helping me! I am so grateful appreciative."


testimonials reviews
"All Charges Dropped & Expunged"

"William defended me in my marijuana + paraphernalia case, he had all charges dropped and expunged! Despite the fact I was long past conditional discharges/probation, etc. He has a sharp wit and a bright future ahead of him as an attorney. Thanks again Will!"


testimonials reviews
"Fantastic Lawyer"

"Mr. Fay is a fantastic lawyer. He helped me during a very stressful time in my life. He was knowledgeable about my case and what my options were. He answered all my questions and was very reassuring. He was there waiting for me at the entrance on my court date and made me feel at ease. He worked with the prosecutor to reduce my charges. I got the best outcome I could have hoped for. I highly recommend Mr. Fay if you need a lawyer."


testimonials reviews
"Marijuana Charges"

"I was arrested and summoned to court for possession of marijuana, even though I didn't have any on me. It was my first time getting in trouble and I was terrified and nervous. Mr. Fay came into court prepared and was extremely assuring. He made it very clear that he was going to fight for my case until the very end. He was extremely knowledgable about my case and the ways to resolve it. I would recommend Mr. Fay to anyone who has gotten into trouble."

former client

testimonials reviews
"Excellent lawyer. Highly recommended."

"Mr. Fay is extremely caring and knowledgeable. He took the time to explain the entire process in a very clear manner and was a tremendous help during a stressful time. He was always available to take a phone call and really showed that he cared about me and my case. I highly recommend Mr. Fay as an attorney." "

former client

testimonials reviews
"Highly recommend"

"Great lawyer. Created a best possible outcome for my case."

former client

testimonials reviews
"Amazing job, explains very clearly"

"He did a fantastic job on my case, making my penalty much less than I thought it could possibly be. He clearly understands what he is doing and can explain everything in a way that anyone can understand. Any questions I had were answered very clearly and he listened to all small details of my case."

former client

Request a Free Consultation

Request a Free Consultation

If you or someone you love has been charged with a criminal or DUI offense in New Jersey, finding the answers you need to make informed decisions is critical. Complete our contact form to request your free consultation or contact 609-832-3202

We are available 24/7 Nights and Weekends to Provide Free Consultations | Hablamos Español