Man Allegedly High on Marijuana, MDMA, Meth During DUI Fatal Accident

Pemberton NJ DUI Lawyer

After a Pemberton Township fatal car accident, authorities in Burlington County have charged a Waterford man with vehicular homicide. The defendant was allegedly driving under the influence of drugs (DUI), including marijuana, MDMA, and methamphetamine, when the crash occurred.

According to officials from the Burlington County Prosecutor’s Office, John P. Randolph, of Waterford Township, was driving his 1993 BMW 325i in the vicinity of Hanover Boulevard and Magnolia Street in the Browns Mills section of Pemberton Township on September 27, 2016. It was early morning and Randolph had a single passenger, 39-year-old Dennis M. McCaffrey Jr., in his car at the time.

Investigators say that Randolph was driving under the influence of marijuana, amphetamine, and methamphetamine when he drove off the road and collided with a tree, killing McCaffrey. Shortly after police arrive on the scene, McCaffrey was pronounced dead. A subsequent blood draw and lab report revealed that Randolph was driving under the influence.

On Thursday, June 8, 2017, nearly a year since the fatal accident, Randolph was indicted on charges for vehicular manslaughter by a grand jury in Burlington County Superior Court in Mount Holly. He was already being held at Burlington County Jail on charges associated with another case. The recent indictment could spell catastrophic consequences for Randolph, as vehicular homicide is the worst case scenario in a New Jersey DUI case.

In New Jersey, a typical charge for DUI, whether the substance involved is marijuana, MDMA, methamphetamine, cocaine, heroin, or prescription drugs, can still expose you to serious penalties. Under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50, a conviction for drug DUI is punishable by a fine of up to $500, loss of your driver’s license for 7 months to 1 year, and up to 30 days in jail. On top of these penalties, you may face additional charges for drug possession or possession of CDS in a motor vehicle if there were drugs in the car at the time of the offense.

In this case, Randolph is also charged with vehicular homicide, also known as death by auto, because the accident resulted in the death of another person. Under New Jersey law (N.J.S.A. 2C:11-5), a person can be charged with death by auto if he or she drives recklessly and causes another person’s death. While reckless driving can mean any number of things, in this case, driving under the influence of drugs meets the requirement for reckless operation of a motor vehicle.

A conviction for vehicular homicide (death by auto) is New Jersey may mean a sentence to serve between 5 and 10 years in New Jersey State Prison, 85 percent of which must be served before the defendant becomes eligible for parole, as well as driver’s license suspension from 5 years to the remainder of your life, and a fine of up to $150,000.

For additional information related to this case, view the following article: Man charged with homicide after fatal 2016 wreck, authorities say


testimonials reviews
"Excellent criminal defense lawyer"

"William handled a matter for me and exceeded my expectations. He was excellent in all areas of the law and achieved an outstanding result. Best of all,he demonstrates honesty and integrity. I would highly recommend William and already have."


testimonials reviews

"I was so scared and nervous about my legal situation but Mr. Fay did an outstanding job with my case!!! I was so relieved with the outcome and he worked so hard for me! He was so calm and understanding and I’m so grateful for him. Thank you so very much for helping me! I am so grateful appreciative."


testimonials reviews
"All Charges Dropped & Expunged"

"William defended me in my marijuana + paraphernalia case, he had all charges dropped and expunged! Despite the fact I was long past conditional discharges/probation, etc. He has a sharp wit and a bright future ahead of him as an attorney. Thanks again Will!"


testimonials reviews
"Fantastic Lawyer"

"Mr. Fay is a fantastic lawyer. He helped me during a very stressful time in my life. He was knowledgeable about my case and what my options were. He answered all my questions and was very reassuring. He was there waiting for me at the entrance on my court date and made me feel at ease. He worked with the prosecutor to reduce my charges. I got the best outcome I could have hoped for. I highly recommend Mr. Fay if you need a lawyer."


testimonials reviews
"Marijuana Charges"

"I was arrested and summoned to court for possession of marijuana, even though I didn't have any on me. It was my first time getting in trouble and I was terrified and nervous. Mr. Fay came into court prepared and was extremely assuring. He made it very clear that he was going to fight for my case until the very end. He was extremely knowledgable about my case and the ways to resolve it. I would recommend Mr. Fay to anyone who has gotten into trouble."

former client

testimonials reviews
"Excellent lawyer. Highly recommended."

"Mr. Fay is extremely caring and knowledgeable. He took the time to explain the entire process in a very clear manner and was a tremendous help during a stressful time. He was always available to take a phone call and really showed that he cared about me and my case. I highly recommend Mr. Fay as an attorney." "

former client

testimonials reviews
"Highly recommend"

"Great lawyer. Created a best possible outcome for my case."

former client

testimonials reviews
"Amazing job, explains very clearly"

"He did a fantastic job on my case, making my penalty much less than I thought it could possibly be. He clearly understands what he is doing and can explain everything in a way that anyone can understand. Any questions I had were answered very clearly and he listened to all small details of my case."

former client

Request a Free Consultation

Request a Free Consultation

If you or someone you love has been charged with a criminal or DUI offense in New Jersey, finding the answers you need to make informed decisions is critical. Complete our contact form to request your free consultation or contact 609-832-3202

We are available 24/7 Nights and Weekends to Provide Free Consultations | Hablamos Español